Goodfellas Pizza

Discover delicious NY-style pizza and tasty Italian favorites at Goodfellas Pizza in Sebastian, FL. Enjoy custom pies, garlic knots, fried zucchini, and more in a friendly setting. Call +1 772-388-0048 or visit us today!

Welcome to Goodfellas Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Goodfellas Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza

Goodfellas Pizza captures the essence of authentic New York-style pizza in Sebastian, Florida. Located at 9615 US-1, this restaurant stands out with its warm, inviting atmosphere and vibrant community vibe. The menu boasts a variety of delicious options, from classic thin-crust slices to gourmet stuffed rolls that cater to every taste. Garlic knots and chicken parmesan create the perfect sides to complement your pizza choice, inviting diners to indulge and enjoy every bite.

Whether grabbing a quick lunch or hosting a lively dinner with friends, Goodfellas Pizza delivers a satisfying experience in a friendly setting. With just a phone call at +1 772-388-0048 away, your cravings for authentic pizza can be met without hassle. You might even enjoy a fun gameday special while surrounded by fellow pizza lovers.

Goodfellas Pizza offers an impressive range of features that elevate the dining experience. First, the iconic 18-inch pizza makes it a perfect choice for gatherings, ensuring no one leaves hungry. The menu includes various gluten-free and cauliflower crust options to cater to diverse dietary needs. Appetizers like buffalo chicken fingers and fried zucchini provide the ideal start to your meal. For those looking for something a little lighter, Greek salads are also available, expertly crafted with fresh ingredients.

Additionally, their commitment to high-quality flavors makes every dish stand out.

The atmosphere is lively, with friendly staff members welcoming guests like family, and the decor often reflects local pride, adding to the community-centric vibe. With a space that holds a bustling but friendly environment, you find the perfect spot to unwind after a busy day.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

9615 US-1, Sebastian, FL 32958, United States

Phone

+1 772-388-0048

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Goodfellas Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza

Goodfellas Pizza serves the Sebastian community with dedication and flair. Since opening its doors, this establishment has become a beloved local haunt, celebrated not just for its pizzas but for its warmth and welcoming environment. The menu showcases an extensive selection of pizzas, slices, and unique offerings. Diners can discover specialty pies that are a feast for the senses, with flavors crafted to excite the palate.

Each pizza is made with attention to detail, using quality ingredients to ensure every bite bursts with flavor.

Popular items like the grandma pizza or the stuffed crust leave patrons returning for more. Those who prefer a hearty meal can opt for chicken parmesan or the crispy fried zucchini. Goodfellas is more than a place to eat; it's a community gathering space where friends and families come together to celebrate life with good food.

Catering is a strong suit here, aptly fitting for the local need to celebrate events and special occasions.

A range of party platters and custom orders allow for seamless gatherings, making it easier to focus on enjoying time with loved ones. Regular diners often rave about the special deals and weekday promotions, adding to the charm of this community staple. Through the highs and lows of daily life, Goodfellas Pizza stands as a beacon of comfort food and camaraderie.

Goodfellas Pizza

The exterior of Goodfellas Pizza mirrors its vibrant personality. A casual yet inviting facade welcomes guests to step inside for a delightful meal. Bright signage and inviting windows allow diners to catch glimpses of the lively atmosphere and enjoy the aroma of freshly baked pizzas filling the air. Outdoor seating options enhance the experience, giving a pleasant al fresco vibe to those looking to enjoy their meals in the beautiful Florida weather.

Amid the hustle of US-1, the restaurant offers a short escape into a warm and neighborly environment, perfect for friendly gatherings or casual dinners.

It's not just about the food here; it's about building bonds within the community. The vibe inside captures a classic pizzeria feel, where laughter and conversation flow as freely as the beverages.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-10 PM
  • Monday10 AM-10 PM
  • Tuesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-10 PM
  • Friday10 AM-11 PM
  • Saturday10 AM-11 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

I got a burger and fries from the lunch special, which was only $8.99. The meal I ordered was really good and so was the service, courtesy, and kindness from the manager (I'm assuming new) and the waitress. It was a lot of food for a great price, other maybe the tomatoes which were a bit off (not bad), everything was really good from the burger, down to the fries. Thank you. Also their brownies are the bomb haha

F
Furry S.

Last night we were in a different town looking for somewhere local to eat and came across this place. When we went in it looked like they were closing down however they served us right away. The cook brought out the hot fresh pizza. I'm so glad we stopped there and my wife loved the pizza and the pizza pepperoni roll thing that I had was delicious as well. The crust was nice and crunchy , food hot and flavorful. Will definitely return and spread the word!

J
Joshua M.

Whaddya want? It's a pizza joint! We ordered a 16" cheese and their 18" Hawaiian which they make with bacon. New York style, with a delicious crust. We also had the garlic knots, which were dry, served with no sauce.

C
Christopher B.

I have had many good experiences here; its nice that they are open late with slices vailable. They have a good 2 pizza slice drink combo. Always a friendly employee taking my order. Served nice and hot. Wasn't impressed with the garlic knots, but that's just my preference. The margherita pizza is very good.

K
Kyle B.

Food is always good and fresh. Service is friendly and very efficient. Prices are a bit high.

T
Tom C.

We stopped in for a slice of pizza. We are Italian and come from NY/NJ so we know good pizza! We have been trying pizza all over this area and I thought I had Covid as I could not taste anything with the other places but I am so happy to say vittorio's pizza is delicious!! It's thin and has great taste! The sauce is very good too!! Can't wait to come back and get a whole pie!! Woohoo

M
Maria W.