Goodfellas Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Goodfellas Pizza serves a mouthwatering variety of over 76 menu items that cater to every craving. When visiting this beloved spot in Sebastian, you're in for a treat. From classic New York-style pizzas to delicious garlic knots, the menu boasts options for everyone. Have a delightful slice of the thin crust or opt for the mighty 18-inch pie that satisfies every hunger pang. Dive into their appetizers like chicken fingers or buffalo chicken fingers, which lead the way for a hearty meal. Don't miss the pasta dishes and the unique stuffed pizza that stands out as a local favorite. Whether ordering for a cozy night in or a catering event, Goodfellas delivers!

APPETIZERS
PIZZA
SLICE PIZZA'S
SOUPS
SALADS
WINGS
CALZONES
STROMBOLI
GOURMET STUFFED ROLLS
COLD SUBS
HOT SUBS
PASTA DISHES
PASTA DISHES BAKED
ENTREES
DESSERTS
BEVERAGES
SPECIALS
MISC ITEMS
CATERING STARTERS AND SIDES
CATERING WINGS
CATERING SALADS
CATERING STROMBOLIS & PIZZA
CATERING ENTREE'S
CATERING PASTAS
CATERING BAKED PASTAS
CATERING SUB PLATTERS
CATERING DESSERTS
CATERING MISC
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 1
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 2
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 3
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 4
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 5
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 6
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 7
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 8
Goodfellas Pizza Menu image 9
Goodfellas Pizza

Goodfellas Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Goodfellas Pizza feels instantly welcoming. The decor embraces a cozy diner vibe, complete with comfortable booths and vibrant wall art. The ambiance buzzes with laughter and chatter, enhancing the friendly atmosphere. Diners find it easy to relax while enjoying their meals, making it a great spot for families and friends alike. The open kitchen provides an enticing view of the culinary action, from pizza being tossed to the smell of baked goods wafting through the air. This lively space matches the energetic spirit of Sebastian, making it a delightful eatery to enjoy local flavors.

Goodfellas Pizza

About Goodfellas Pizza Food and Specialties

Goodfellas Pizza takes pride in offering distinctive food that captures the essence of Italian-American cuisine. The signature NY-style pizza tends to attract repeat customers with its perfectly balanced cheese and sauce ratio. Renowned for their garlic knots, these fluffy delights complement any meal. Patrons rave about the chicken parm, a hearty choice that satisfies any meat lover. Other noteworthy specialties include the deep-fried zucchini and custom pies, which allow diners to create their flavors. Goodfellas also provides catering options, showcasing a Greek salad that adds freshness to any feast. A hidden gem is the cauliflower crust, perfect for health-conscious diners.

Goodfellas Pizza

Goodfellas Pizza commits itself to excellence, prioritizing customer satisfaction and quality. The goal is to deliver the best pizza experience in Sebastian, and they accomplish this by carefully sourcing their ingredients and perfecting their recipes. Their specialty lies in creating outstanding pizzas but extends to a wide array of dishes that showcase culinary skill and passion for food. Every meal aims to exceed customer expectations, turning first-time visitors into regulars.

The vision for Goodfellas Pizza goes beyond serving delicious meals; it's about creating moments and memories.

Events and community gatherings often fill the restaurant, showcasing the friendliness and warmth that defines Sebastian. By embracing the local culture, Goodfellas Pizza becomes not just a dining spot but a part of the community fabric, nurturing connections between neighbors and friends through the love of pizza.